Related:

• I guess the rule is, if something's too good to be true, then it's probably too good to be true.
  -- Marshall, The ATM Machine, Eerie Indiana...
• It is good news, worthy of all acceptation; and yet not too good to be true.
  -- Mathew Henry (1662-1714) -- Commentaries, Timothy i...
• A good stroke, but it's too slow, the # dodges.
• Too much of a good thing is WONDERFUL. -- Mae We
• Note: Chocolate syrup is good on ice cream, too.