Masnavi 6

HomeIranPoetryMowlana Jalaluddin Rumi - Masnavi Manavi


Book VI.


O LIFE of the heart, Husamu-'d-Din,
My zeal burnt within me to write this sixth part!
The Masnavi became a standard through thy influence,
Thy sword (Husam) has made it an exemplar to the world
O spiritual one, I now offer it to thee,
This sixth part of the entire Masnavi.
Enlighten the world's six sides with its six parts,
That it may illuminate him who is not illuminated!
Love has naught to do with five senses or six sides,
Its only aim is to be attracted to the Beloved!
But haply leave may be given me hereafter
To tell those mysteries so far as they can be told,
In a discourse more closely approximating to the facts
Than these faint indications of those abstruse matters.
Mysteries are not communicable, save to those who know;
Mystery in the ear of infidels is no mystery.
Nevertheless, this is a call to you from God;
It matters not to Him whether ye accept or reject it.
Noah repeated His call for nine hundred years,
But his people only increased in rebellion.
Never did he draw back from admonishing them,
Never did he retire into the cave of silence.
He said, "At the barking and howling of the dogs
No caravan ever turned back in its road.
Nor does the full moon on a bright night cease shining
Because of the howling of dogs on earth.
The moon sheds her light, and the dogs howl;
Every one acts according to his nature.
To each one his office is allotted by the divine decree,
And he acts agreeably to his nature."
Art thou thirsting for the Ocean of spirituality?
Disport thyself on this island of the Masnavi!
Disport thyself so long as thou seest every moment
Spiritual verities revealed in this Masnavi.
When the wind blows the grass off the water,
The water then shows forth its own purity.
Behold the bright and fresh sprays of coral,
And the princely fruits growing in the water of life!
So, when the Masnavi is purged of letters and words,
It drops all these, and appears as the sea of Unity.
Then speaker and hearer and spoken words
All three give up the ghost in that consummation.
Bread-giver and bread-eater and bread itself
Are purified of their forms and turn to dust.
But their essences in each of these three grades
Are distinguished, as in those states, so eternally. 1
Their form turns to dust, but their essence not;
If one says it does, tell him it does not.
In the world of spirits all three await judgment,
Sometimes wearing their earthly forms, sometimes not.
The worth of a man depends on the objects of his aspiration.
One day a student asked a preacher,
Saying, "O most orthodox ornament of the pulpit,
I have a question to ask, O lord of learning;
Tell me the answer to it in this congregation.
A bird sat on the top of a wall;
Which was best, its head or its tail?"
He replied, "If its face was towards the town,
And its tail to the villages, then its face was best.
But if its tail was towards the town, and its face
Towards the villages, then prefer its tail to its face."
A bird flies with its wings towards its nest,
The wings of a man are his aspiration and aim.
If a lover be befouled with good and evil,
Yet regard not these; regard rather his aspiration.
Though a falcon be all white and unmatched in form,
If he hunts mice he is contemptible and worthless.
And if an owl fixes his affection on the king,
He is a falcon in reality; regard not his outward form.
Adam's clay was kneaded in the limits of a trough,
Yet was he exalted above heaven and stars.
"We have honored Adam" 2 was not addressed to the sky,
But to Adam himself full of defects as he was.
Did one ever propose to earth or heaven to receive
Beauty, reason, speech and aspiration? 3
Would you ever offer to the heavens
Beauty of face and acuteness of thought?
O son, did you ever present your silver body
As an offering to the damsels pictured on bath walls?
Nay, you pass by those pictures though fair as Huris,
And offer yourself sooner to half-blind old women.
What is there in the old women which the pictures lack,
Which draws you from the pictures to the old women?
Say not, for I will say it in plain words,
'Tis reason, sense, perception, thought, and life.
In the old woman life is infused,
While the pictures of the bath have no life.
If the pictures of the bath should stir with life (soul),
They would uproot your love to all the old women.
What is soul? 'Tis acquainted with good and evil,
Rejoicing at pleasant things, grieving at His.
Since, then, the principle of soul is knowledge,
He who knows most is most full of soul.
Knowledge is the effect flowing from soul;
He who has most of it is most godlike.
Seeing then, beloved, that knowledge is the mark of soul,
He who knows most has the strongest soul.
The world of souls is itself entirely knowledge,
And he who is void of knowledge is void of soul.
When knowledge is lacking in a man s nature,
His soul is like a stone on the plain.
Primal Soul is the theatre of God's court,
Soul of souls the exhibition of God Himself.
All the angels were pure reason and soul,
Yet when the new soul of Adam came, they were as its body.
When in joy they crowded round that new soul, 4
They bowed before it as body does before soul.
Fear of men's censure the greatest obstacle to acceptance of the true faith.
O Husamu-'d-Din, I might tell some of thy many virtues,
Were it not for the fear of the evil eyes.
From evil eyes and malice-empoisoned breaths
Already have I suffered fatal wounds.
Therefore I cannot relate thy ecstatic states,
Save by hints of the ecstatic states of others.
This manoeuvre is one of the devices of the heart,
Whereby the heart's feet wend their way to the truth.
Many hearts and souls would become lovers of God
Did not evil eyes or evil ears hold them back.
Of these Abu Talib, the Prophet's uncle, was one;
The malice of the Arabs scared him from the faith.
He said, "What will the Arabs say of me?
That my own nephew has perverted me from my religion!"
Muhammad said, "O uncle, confess the faith to me,
That I may strive with God for thee!"
He said, "Nay; it will be published by them that hear;
'A secret known to more than two is known to every one.' 5
As I live in the midst of these Arabs,
It will cause me to lose caste with them.
Yet, had the mighty grace of God led the way,
How could this fear have vied with God's attraction?
O Granter of aid, lend us aid
In this dilemma of the feeble will.
Prayers for right guidance in the use of free will, which gift was refused
by heavens and earth, but accepted by man to his own. 6
This flux and reflux of resolves came to me from Thee,
Else these tides of will had rested still, O God!
By the same fiat whereby Thou madest me thus irresolute,
Of Thy mercy deliver me from this irresolution!
Thou triest me; O give me aid!
For men are as women through this trial.
How long, O Lord, is this trial to last?
Give me one ruling principle, not ten principles!
The whole world flees away from its own will and being
Towards self-abandonment and intoxication.
In order to escape a while from self-consciousness,
Men incur the reproach of wine and strong drink;
For all know well this existence is a snare,
This thought and memory and will only a hell.
Therefore they flee from self to being beside themselves,
Call it intoxication or call it preoccupation, O guided one.
Ere it is annihilated, no single soul
Finds admittance to the divine hall of audience.
What is "ascension" to heaven? Annihilation of self;
Self-abandonment is the creed and religion of lovers.
1. Koran xxxvi. 32: "But all gathered together shall be set before us."
2. Koran xvii. 72.
3. "We proposed to the heavens and to the earth to receive the deposit, but
they refused the burden. Man undertook to bear it, but bath proved unjust
and senseless" (Koran xxxiii. 72).
4. "We said unto the angels, 'Prostrate yourselves before Adam,' and they
prostrated themselves, except Iblis" (Koran vi. 10).
5. Freytag, Arabum Proverbia, iii. 222.
6. Koran xxxiii. 72, quoted above. "Deposit" is here interpreted of the
will, the ability to go right or wrong.

The Hindu Slave who loved his Master's Daughter.
A certain man had a Hindu slave, whom he had brought up along with his
children, one of whom was a daughter. When the time came for giving the girl
in marriage many suitors presented themselves, and offered large marriage
portions to gain her alliance. At last her father selected one who was by no
means the richest or noblest of the number, but pious and well-mannered. The
women of the family would have preferred one of the richer youths, but the
father insisted on having his own way, and the marriage was settled
according to his wishes. As soon as the Hindu slave heard of this he fell
sick, and the mistress of the family discovered that he was in love with her
daughter, and aspired to the honor of marrying her. She was much discomposed
at this unfortunate accident, and consulted her husband as to what was best
to be done. He said, "Keep the affair quiet, and I will cure the slave of
his presumption, in such a way that, according to the proverb, 'The Shaikh
shall not be burnt, yet the meat shall be well roasted.'" He directed his
wife to flatter the slave with the hope that his wish would be granted, and
the girl given to him in marriage. He then celebrated a mock marriage
between the slave and the girl, but at night substituted for the girl a boy
dressed in female attire, with the result that the bridegroom passed the
night in quarrelling with his supposed bride. Next morning he had an
interview with the girl and her mother, and said he would have no more to do
with her, as, though her appearance was very seductive at a distance, closer
acquaintance with her had altogether destroyed the charm. Just so the
pleasures of the world seem sweet till they are tried, and then they are
found to be very bitter and repulsive. The Prophet has declared that
"Patience is the key of joy;" 1 in other words, that he who controls and
restrains himself from grasping at worldly pleasures will find true
happiness; but this precept makes no lasting impression on the bulk of
mankind. When bitter experience overtakes them, as the pain of burning
afflicts children, or moths sporting with fire, or the pain of amputation a
thief, they curse the delusive temptations which brought this pain upon
them; but no sooner is the pain abated than they run after the same
pleasures as eagerly as ever. This is divinely ordained, that "God may bring
to naught the craft of the infidels." 2 Their hearts have, as it were, been
kindled on the tinder-box of bitter experience, but God has put out the
sparks of good resolution, and caused them to forget their experience and
vows of abstinence according to the text, "Often as they kindle a
beacon-fire for war doth God quench it." 3 This is illustrated by an
anecdote of a man who heard a footstep in his house at night, and at once
struck a light; but the thief put it out without being observed, and the man
remained under the impression that it had gone out of itself. This leads the
poet again to dwell on his favorite theme of the sole agency of Allah.
Then, to supply the necessary corrective of this doctrine, another anecdote
is told concerning Mahmud and Ayaz. The courtiers grumbled because Ayaz
received the stipend of thirty courtiers, and Mahmud by a practical test
convinced them that the talents of Ayaz equalled those of thirty men. The
courtiers replied that this was due to God's grace, not to any merit on the
part of Ayaz; and the king confuted them by pointing out that man's
responsibility and merit, or demerit, for his actions are recognized in the
Koran. Iblis was condemned for saying to God, "Thou hast caused me to err,"
4 and Adam was commended or saying, "We have blackened ourselves." 5 And
elsewhere it is said, "Whosoever shall have wrought an atom's weight of good
shall behold it; and whoso shall have wrought an atom's weight of evil shall
behold it." 6
1. Freytag, Arabum Proverbia, iii. 270.
2. Koran viii. 18.
3. Koran v. 69.
4. Koran vii. 15 and 22.
5. Koran vii. 15 and 22.
6. Koran xcix. 7.

The Fowler and the Bird.
A fowler went out to catch birds, and disguised himself by wrapping his head
up in leaves and grass, so as to avoid frightening the birds away from his
snare. A bird of some sagacity came near him, and suspected something wrong,
but foolishly lingered near, and began to question him as to his business.
The fowler said he was a hermit who had retired from the world and dressed
himself in weeds for the health of his soul. The bird said he was surprised
to see a Mosalman doing this in contravention of the Prophet's precept,
"There is no monkery in Islam," and his repeated declarations that Islam
involves association with the faithful and avoidance of a solitary life. The
fowler replied that a solitary life was allowed in heathen countries for the
soul's health. 1 The bird then asked what the grains of wheat were that were
strewed on the trap. The fowler replied that they were the property of an
orphan, which had been deposited with him in consequence of his known
probity. The bird then asked permission to eat some, as he was very hungry,
and the fowler, with much pretended reluctance, allowed him to do so. The
moment he touched the grain the trap closed upon him, and he found himself a
prisoner. He then abused the fowler for his trickery, but the fowler said he
had only himself to blame for his greediness in eating the food which
belonged to an orphan. The moral is, that it is not destiny which leads
people into afflictions, but their own errors and vices.
The bird's cries to God for aid.
When he had eaten the grain he was caught in the trap,
And began to recite the chapters "Yasin" and "An'am."
Then he began to wail and cry loudly,
So that the very fowler and his trap shook with grief.
He said, "My back is broken by the conflict of my thoughts;
O Beloved One, come and stroke my head in mercy!
The palm of Thy hand on my head gives me rest,
Thy hand is a sign of Thy bounteous providence.
Remove not Thy shadow from my head,
I am afflicted, afflicted, afflicted!
Sleep has deserted my eyes
Through my longing for Thee, O Envy of cypresses!
Though I be unworthy of Thy favor, how were it
If thou shouldst regard the grieves of unworthy me?
What claim of right can a non-existent thing make
To have the doors of Thy bounty opened to it?
Yet Thy bounty had regard to my senseless dust
And endued it with the ten jewels of the senses
Five external senses and five internal senses,
Whereby inanimate seed became a living man.
O Light on high! what is repentance without Thy grace
But a mere mockery of the beard of repentance;
Thou rootest up the hairs of such repentance,
Repentance is the shadow, Thou the shining Moon.
Alas! Thou hast ruined my house and home;
How can I cease wailing while Thou oppressest me?
How can I flee away when there is no living away?
Without Thy sustaining lordship there is no slave.
O take my life, Thou that art the source of life!
For apart from Thee I am wearied of my life.
I am a lover well versed in lovers' madness,
I am weary of learning and sense.
Since my bashfulness is destroyed, I will publish secrets;
How long must I bear this trepidation and anxiety?
Formerly I was covered by modesty as by a veil,
Now I will leap from it under Thy coverlet!
O comrades, our Beloved has closed up all paths;
We are as lame deer, and He as a raging lion.
Say what remedy is there but resignation 2
When one is fallen into the hands of the raging lion?"
The poet then passes on to the subject of the need for constant
watchfulness, in order to avoid the snares of the world, and not to miss the
divine blessing whenever it may appear. There is a tradition, "When half the
night has passed Allah will descend to earth, and cry, 'Ho, ye that ask, it
shall be answered to you; and ye that crave pardon, it shall be pardoned to
you; and ye that petition, your petitions shall be granted.'" But all who
sleep the sleep of negligence will miss the promised blessing. This is
illustrated by the story of a lover who obtained an assignation with his
mistress, but when she came, was found asleep, and was accordingly rejected.
1. See Miskkat ul Masabih, ii. 541.
2. "To God I commit my case" (Koran xl. 47).

The Drunken Turkish Amir and the Minstrel.
Then follow exhortations to undergo "the pains of negation," as they are
called in the Gulshan i Raz, i.e., even as the great saint and poet
Faridu-'d-Din 'Attar cast away his drugs, to cast one's own will, knowledge,
power, and ''self" into the unique river of "annihilation," 1 and from that
state to rise to the higher state of eternal existence in God. The end and
object of all negation is to attain to subsequent affirmation, as the
negation in the creed, "There is no God," finds its complement and purpose
in the affirmation "but God." Just so the purpose of negation of self is to
clear the way for the apprehension of the fact that there is no existence
but The One. The intoxication of life and its pleasures and occupations
veils the Truth from men's eyes, and they ought to pass on to the spiritual
intoxication which makes men beside themselves and lifts them to the
beatific vision of eternal Truth. This is the same thing as saying they must
pass on from negation to affirmation, from ignorance to the highest
knowledge. This is illustrated by the story of the Turkish noble and the
minstrel, which is given with an apology for using illustrations derived
from drunkenness. A Turkish noble awoke from his drunken sleep, and called
his minstrel to enliven him. The minstrel was a spiritual man, and proceeded
to improve the occasion by singing a song with a deep spiritual meaning:
"I know not if thou art a moon or an idol,
I know not what thou requirest of me.
I know not what service to pay thee,
Whether to keep silence or to speak.
Thou art not apart from me, yet, strange to say,
I know not where I am, or where thou art.
I know not wherefore thou art dragging me,
Now embracing me, and now wounding me!"
Thus the whole of his song consisted of repetitions of the words, "I know
not." At last the noble could endure it no longer, and he took a stick and
threatened to beat the minstrel, saying, "O wretch, tell us something you do
know, and do not repeat what you do not know. if I ask you whence you come
or what you have eaten, and you answer only by negations, your answer is a
waste of time. Say what you mean by all these negations." The minstrel
replied, "My meaning is a concealed one. I fear to make affirmations in
opposition to your negations, so I state negations that you may get a hint
of the corresponding affirmations from them. I now hint the truth to you in
my song; and when death comes to you, you will learn the mysteries which at
present I can only hint."
Spiritual mysteries set forth in the Masnavi under similes of intoxication.
That wine of God is gained from that minstrel, 2
This bodily wine from this minstrel.
Both of these have one and the same name in speech,
But the difference between their worth is great.
Men's bodies are like pitchers with closed mouths;
Beware, till you see what is inside them.
The pitcher of this body holds the water of life,
Whilst that one holds deadly poison.
If you look at the contents you are wise;
If you look only at the vessel you are misguided.
Know words resemble these bodies,
And the meaning resembles the soul.
The body's eyes are ever intent on bodies,
The soul's eyes on the reasonable soul;
Wherefore, in the figures of the words of the Masnavi,
The form misleads, but the inner meaning guides.
In the Koran it is declared that its parables
"Mislead some and guide some." 3
O God! when a spiritual man talks of wine,
How can a fellow spiritual man mistake his meaning?
Thus that minstrel began his intoxicating song,
"O give me Thy cup, Thou whom I see not!
Thou art my face; what wonder if I see it not?
Extreme nearness acts as an obscuring veil. 4
Thou art my reason; what wonder if I see Thee not
Through the multitude of intervening obstacles?
Thou art 'nearer to me than my neck vein,' 5
How can I call to Thee, 'Ho,' as if thou wert far off?
Nay, but I will mislead some by calling in the desert,
To hide my Beloved from those of whom I am jealous!"
This is illustrated by an anecdote of the Prophet and Ayisha. Ayisha was
once sitting with the Prophet without her veil, when a blind man came in.
Ayisha, knowing well the jealous disposition of her husband, at once
prepared to retire on which the Prophet said, "The man is blind and cannot
see you." Ayisha replied by signs that though the man could not see her she
could see him. Just so the spiritual man is jealous of exposing his
mysteries to the gaze of the profane, and from excess of caution veils them
in signs and hints.
Then comes a commentary on the tradition, "Die before you die," i.e.,
mortify your carnal passions and lusts, and deny and annihilate your carnal
" self" before the death of the body overtakes you. Men who put off
repentance till they are at the point of death are likened to the Shi'as of
Aleppo, who every year on the Ashura, or tenth day of Muharram, meet at the
Antioch gate to bewail the martyrdom of Hasan and Husain. Once, while they
were thus engaged, a Sunni poet arrived at the city, and inquired the reason
of this excessive grief and mourning. The Shi'as rebuked him for his
ignorance of sacred history, and he said, "This martyrdom happened a long
time ago; but it would seem, from your excessive grief, that the news of it
has only just reached you. You must have been sleeping all this time not to
have heard it before, and now you are mourning for your own sleepiness!" To
the truly spiritual, who have drunk of God's wine and bear the "tokens of it
on their foreheads," 6 death is an occasion for rejoicing, not for wailing.
The man who is engrossed with the trifling pleasures of the world and blind
to the ample provision made for the soul is like an ant in a barn of wheat,
toiling to carry off a single grain, when ample stores of wheat are already
at its disposal. Spiritual men must continue urging the worldly to repent
and avail themselves of this heavenly provision for their souls, careless,
like Noah, whether their preaching is listened to or not. This is
illustrated by an anecdote of a man who knocked at the door of an empty
house at midnight, in order to give notice that it was time to prepare the
meal taken at dawn in Ramazan.
Reason for knocking at the empty house.
You have said your say; now hear my answer,
So as not to remain in astonishment and bewilderment.
Though to you this time seems midnight,
To me the dawn of joyful morn seems nigh.
To the vulgar all parts of the world seem dead,
But to God they are instinct with sense and love.
And as to your saying that "this house is empty,
Why then should I beat a drum before it?"
Know that the people of God expend money,
And build many mosques and holy places,
And spend health and wealth in distant pilgrimages,
In ecstatic delight, like intoxicated lovers;
And none of them ever say, "The Ka'ba is empty;"
How can one who knows the truth say that?
These people are ranged in battle array,
And risk their lives to gain God's favor;
One plunged in calamities like Job himself,
Another exhibiting patience like Jacob.
Thousands of them are thirsty and afflicted,
Striving in earnest desire to do God's will.
I likewise, in order to please the merciful God,
Beat my drum at every door in hope of dawn.
Seek ye a purchaser who will pay you gold;
Where will you find one more liberal than God?
He buys the worthless rubbish which is your wealth,
He pays you the light that illumines your heart.
He accepts these frozen and lifeless bodies of yours,
And gives you a kingdom beyond what you dream of.
He takes a few drops of your tears,
And gives you the divine fount sweeter than sugar.
He takes your sighs fraught with grief and sadness,
And for each sigh gives rank in heaven as interest.
In return for the sigh-wind that raised tear-clouds,
God gave Abraham the title of "Father of the faithful."
Come! in this incomparable and crowded mart
Sell your old goods and take a kingdom in payment!
1. Koran cxii. 4.
2. "A wine cup tempered at the camphor fountain shall the just quaff" (Koran
lxxvi. 5).
3. Koran ii. 24.
4. See couplet 122 of the Guishan i Raz:
"When the object looked at is very close to the eye,
The eye is darkened so that it cannot see it."
I.e., When man is united with God he can no longer behold Him, for he is
dwelling in Him.
5. Koran l. 15.
6. Koran xlviii. 29.

The Purchase of Bilal.
To illustrate the rich recompense that is awarded to those who are faithful
in tribulation, the story of Bilal is next recounted at length. Bilal was an
Abyssinian slave belonging to a Jew of Mecca, and had incurred his master's
displeasure in consequence of having embraced Islam. For this offence his
master tortured him by exposing him to the heat of the midday sun, and
beating him with thorns. But notwithstanding his anguish, Bilal would not
recant his faith, and uttered only the cry, "Ahad, Ahad!" "The One, the One
God!" At this moment Abu Bakr, the "Faithful witness," happened to pass by,
and was so struck by his constancy that he resolved to buy him of the Jew.
After much higgling and attempts at cheating on the Jew's part he succeeded
in doing so, and at once set him free. When the Prophet heard of this
purchase he said to Abu Bakr, "Give me a share in him;" but Abu Bakr told
him, somewhat to his annoyance, that he had already set him free.
Notwithstanding this Bilal attached himself to the Prophet, and was
afterwards promoted to the honourable post of the Prophet's Mu'azzin.
This is followed by the story of Hilal, another holy man who, like Bilal and
Luqman and Joseph, served a noble in the capacity of groom. His affections
were set on things above, and he was ever pressing upwards towards the high
mark of spiritual exaltation, and saying, like Moses, "I will not stop till
I reach the confluence of the two seas, and for years will I journey on." 1
Herein he presented a great contrast to ordinary men, who are ever giving
way to their lusts, and so being dragged down into the state of mere
animals, or even lower. Hilal's master was a Mosalman, yet one whose eyes
were only partially open to the truth. He was in the habit of asking his
guests their age; and if they answered doubtfully, saying, "Perhaps
eighteen, or seventeen, or sixteen, or even fifteen," he would rebuke them,
saying, "As you seem to be putting yourself lower and lower, you had better
go back at once to your mother's womb." These guests are a type of men who
lower themselves from the rank of humanity to that of animals. This master,
however, was blind to Hilal's spiritual excellence, and allowed him to drag
on a miserable existence in his stables. At last Hilal fell sick; but no one
cared for him, till the Prophet himself, warned by a divine intimation, came
to visit him, and commiserated his wretched condition. Hilal proved himself
to be faithful through tribulation; for, instead of grumbling at his lot, he
replied, "How is that sleep wretched which is broken by the advent of the
Sun of prophecy? or how can he be called athirst on whose head is poured the
water of life?" In truth, Hilal had by degrees become purified from the
stain of earthly existence and earthly qualities, and washed in the fountain
of the water of life, i.e., the holy revelations of the Prophet, till he had
attained the exalted grade of purity enjoined on those who would study God's
Word aright. 2
Growth in grace is accomplished by slow degrees, and not per saltum.
Since you have told the story of Hilal (the new moon)
Now set forth the story of Badr (the full moon).
That new moon and that full moon are now united,
Removed from duality and defect and shortcomings.
That Hilal is now exalted above inward defect;
His outward defects served as degrees of ascension.
Night after night that mentor taught him grades of ascent
And through his patient waiting gave him happiness.
The mentor says, "O raw hastener, through patient waiting,
You must climb to the summit step by step.
Boil your pot by degrees and in a masterly way;
Food boiled in mad haste is spoiled.
Doubtless God could have created the universe
By the fiat 'Be!' in one moment of time;
Why, then, did He protract His work over six days,
Each of which equaled a thousand years, O disciple?
Why does the formation of an infant take nine months?
Because God's method is to work by slow degrees,
Why did the formation of Adam take forty days?
Because his clay was kneaded by slow degrees.
Not hurrying on like you, O raw one,
Who claim to be a Shaikh whilst yet only a child!
You run up like a gourd higher than all plants,
But where is your power of resistance or combat?
You have leant on trees or on walls,
And so mounted up like a gourd, O little dog rose;
Even though your prop may be a lofty cypress,
At last you are seen to be dry and hollow.
O gourd, your bright green hue soon turns yellow.
For it is not a natural but an artificial color."
This is illustrated by an anecdote of an ugly old hag who painted her face
to make it look pretty, but was detected and exposed to scorn.
1. Koran xviii. 59.
2. Koran lvi. 79.

The Sufi and the Qazi.
A sick man laboring under an incurable disease went to a physician for
advice. The physician felt his pulse, and perceived that no treatment would
cure him, and therefore told him to go away and do whatever he had a fancy
for. This was the advice given by God to the Israelites when they were seen
to be incurable by the admonitions of the prophets. "Do what you will, but
God's eye is on all your doings." 1 The sick man blessed the physician for
his agreeable prescription, and at once went to a stream, where he saw a
Sufi bathing his feet. He was seized with a desire to hit the Sufi on the
back, and, calling to mind the physician's advice, at once carried his wish
into effect. The Sufi jumped up, and was about to return the blow, but when
he saw the weakly and infirm condition of his assailant he restrained
himself. He disregarded his present angry impulse, and had regard to the
future, so that the non-existent future became to him more really existent
than the existing present. Here the poet digresses to point out that when
wise men recognize the true relative importance of the present and the
future they cease to shrink from death and annihilation, which lifts them to
a higher and nobler life. This is illustrated by an anecdote of Mahmud of
Ghazni, quoted from Faridu- 'd-Din 'Attar. Mahmud, in one of his campaigns,
took prisoner a Hindu boy, who at first regarded him with the greatest
dread, in consequence of the stories he had heard of him from his mother,
but afterwards experienced Mahmud's kindness and tenderness, and came to
know him and love him. So it is with death. According to the Hadis "Those
who have passed away do not grieve because of death, but because of wasted
opportunities in life." The Masnavi is "a shop of poverty and
self-abnegation," and a treasury containing only the doctrines of "Unity;"
and if its stories suggest aught else, that is due to the evil promptings of
Iblis, who also misled the Prophet himself to attribute undue power to the
idols Lat and 'Uzza and Manat, in a verse which was afterwards cancelled. 2
The Sufi, being full of the spirit of self-abnegation, did not retaliate on
his weak, assailant but led him before the Qazi. On learning the facts of
the case the Qazi said, "This Faqir is sick to death, and you, being a Sufi,
are, according to your profession, dead to the world. How, then, can I award
a penalty against him in your favor? I am a judge, not of the dead, but of
the living." The Sufi was dissatisfied with this view of the case, and again
pressed the Qazi to do him justice. On this the Qazi asked the sick Faqir
how much money he had, and on his replying, "Six dirhams," took pity on him,
and let him off with a fine of three dirhams only. The moment the sentence
was pronounced the sick Faqir went up to the Qazi and struck him a blow on
the back, and cried out, "Now take the other three dirhams and let me go!"
The Sufi then pointed out to the Qazi that by his ill-timed leniency to the
Faqir he had brought this blow upon himself, and urged him to apply in his
own case those principles of mercy and forgiveness which he had proposed in
the case of another. The Qazi said that, for his part, he recognized every
blow and misfortune that might befall him as divinely ordained, and sent for
his good, according to the text, "Laugh little and weep much," 3 and that
his judgment in the matter of the Faqir had not been dictated by impulse,
but by inspiration. 4 The Sufi again asked him how evils and misfortunes
could proceed from the divine fount of good, and the Qazi replied that what
seems good and evil to us has no absolute existence, but is merely as the
foam on the surface of the vast ocean. Moreover, every misfortune occurring
to the faithful in this life will be amply compensated for in the life to
come. The Sufi asked why this world should not be so arranged that only good
should be experienced in it, and the Qazi replied by telling him an anecdote
of a Turk and a tailor. The Turk, who typifies the careless pleasure-seeker,
was so intent on listening to the jokes and amusing stories of the tailor,
typifying the seductive world, that he allowed himself to be robbed of the
silk which was to furnish him with a vesture for eternity. The Sufi again
retorted that he did not see why the world would not get on better without
the evil in it, and the Qazi replied with the poet's favorite argument that
there would be no possibility of being virtuous if there were no temptations
to be vicious. As Bishop Butler says, this life is a state of probation, and
such a state necessarily involves trials and difficulties and dangers to be
resisted and overcome.
The dead regret not dying, but having lost opportunities in life.
Well said that Leader of mankind,
That whosoever passes away from the world
Does not grieve and lament over his death,
But grieves ever over lost opportunities.
He says, "Why did I not keep death always in view,
Which is the treasury of wealth and sustenance?
Why did I blindly all my life set my affections
On vain shadows which perish at death?
My regret is not that I have died,
But that I rested on these vain shadows in life.
I saw not that my body was a mere shadow or foam,
Which foam rises out of and lives on the Ocean (God).
When the Ocean casts its foam-drops to land,
Go to the graveyard and behold them,
And ask them, "Where is your motion and activity?
The Ocean has cast you into a mortal sickness!"
They will answer by their condition, if not with words,
"Put this question to the Ocean, not to us!"
How can mere foam move unless moved by the waves?
How can dust mount on high unless raised by wind?
When you see the dust-cloud, see the wind too!
When you see the foam, see the ocean that heaves it!
Ah! look till you see your own real final cause,
The rest of you is only fat and flesh, warp and woof.
Your fat kindles no light or flame in a lamp;
Your kneaded flesh is not good for roasting.
Burn up, then, all this body of yours with discernment;
Rise to sight, to sight, to sight!
Virtue cannot exist without temptation and difficulties to be overcome.
The Sufi said, "The Great Helper is able
To procure for us profit without loss.
He who casts into the fire roses and trees
Can accomplish good without injury to any.
He who extracts the rose from the thorn
Can also turn this winter into spring.
He who exalts the heads of the cypresses
Is able also out of sadness to bring joy.
He by whose fiat all non-existent things exist,
What harm to Him were it if He made them eternal?
He who gave to the body a soul and made it live,
What loss to Him were it if He never caused it to die?
How would it be if That Liberal One were to give
Their hearts' desire to his slaves without toil,
And keep away from these feeble ones
The ambushed snares of lust and temptations of Iblis?"
The Qazi said, "If there were no bitter things,
And no opposition of fair and foul, stone and pearl,
And no lust or Satan or concupiscence,
And no wounds or war or fraud,
Pray, O destroyer of virtue, by what name and title
Could the King of kings address His slaves?
How could He say, 'O temperate or O meek one!'
Or, 'O courageous one, or O wise one?'
How could there be temperate, gentle, or liberal men
If there were no cursed Satan to tempt them astray?
Rustam and Hamza would be all the same as cowards;
Wisdom and knowledge would be useless and vain.
Wisdom and knowledge serve to guide the wanderers;
Were there but one road wisdom would be needless.
To pamper the house of your body fleeting as water,
Do you think it right to ruin both worlds?
I know you are pure of guile and ripe,
And ask this only to edify the ignorant.
The ills of fortune and all troubles soever
Are better than exile from God and neglect of Him;
For the former pass away, but the latter abide;
He is happy who carries a wary heart before God." 5
This is illustrated by an anecdote of a woman who complained of the hard
life she had to lead with her husband owing to his poverty, and was silenced
by being asked whether she would prefer to be divorced. No troubles are so
hard to hear as separation from the Beloved. Fasting and holy war bring
pains with them, but not so great as those incurred by banishment from God.
In the midst of their troubles God is ever caring for His servants, and they
must not let their tribulations blot out the memory of God's previous
goodness to them.
To do this shows an entire absence of growth in grace. This is illustrated
by an anecdote of a sage and a monk. The sage asked the monk which was the
older, his white beard or himself. The monk replied that he himself was
older by some years, whereupon the sage rebuked him for his ignorance,
saying his beard had grown pure and white, but he was still black with sin,
and had progressed not at all in goodness since he was born.
Each of our members testifies to God's bounties towards us.
Inquire now, I pray, of each one of your members;
These dumb members have a thousand tongues.
Inquire the detail of the bounties of the All-sustainer,
Which are recorded in the volume of the universe.
Day and night you are eagerly asking for news,
Whilst every member of your body is telling you news.
Since each member of your body issued from Not-being,
How much pleasure has it seen, and how much pain?
For no member grows and flourishes without pleasure,
And each member is weakened by every pain. 6
The member endures, but that pleasure is forgotten,
Yet not all forgotten, but hidden from the senses.
Like summer wherein cotton is produced,
The cotton remains, but the summer is forgotten.
Or like ice which is formed in great frost,
The frost departs, but the ice is still before us.
The ice is mindful of that extreme cold,
And even in winter that crop is mindful of the summer.
In like manner, O son, every member of your body
Tells you tales of God's bounties to your body.
Even as a woman who has borne twenty children,
Each child tells a tale of pleasure felt by her.
She became not pregnant save after sexual pleasure,
Can a garden bloom without the spring?
Pregnant women and their teeming wombs
Tell tales of love frolics in the spring.
So every tree which nurtures its fruits
Has been, like Mary, impregnated by the Unseen King.
Though fire's heat be hidden in the midst of water,
Yet a thousand boiling bubbles prove it present.
Though the heat of the fire be working unseen,
Yet its bubbles signify its presence plainly.
In like manner, the members of those enjoying "union"
Become big with child, viz., with forms of "states" and "words." 7
Gazing on the beauty of these forms they stand agape,
And the forms of the world vanish from their sight.
These spiritual progenies are not born of the elements,
And are perforce invisible to the sensual eye.
These progenies are born of divine apparitions,
And are therefore bidden by veils without color.
I said "born," but in reality they are not born;
I used this expression only by way of indication.
But keep silence till the King bids you speak,
Offer not your nightingale songs to these roses;
For they themselves are saying to you in loud tones,
"O nightingale, hold your peace, and listen to us!"
Those two kinds of fair forms (ecstatic states and words)
Are undeniable proofs of a previous "union;"
Yea, those two kinds of exalted manifestations
Are the evident fruits of a preceding wedlock.
The ecstasy is past, but your members recall it;
Ask them about it, or call it to mind yourself.
When sorrow seizes you, if you are wise,
You will question that sorrow-fraught moment,
Saying to it, "O sorrow, who now deniest
Thy portion of bounty given thee by the Perfect One,
Even if each moment be not to thee a glad spring,
Yet of what is thy body, like a rose-heap, a storehouse?
Thy body is a heap of roses, thy thought rosewater;
'Twere strange if rosewater ignored the rose-heap!"
1. Koran xli. 40.
2. Koran liii. 19, and Rodwell's note.
3. Koran ix. 84.
4. Koran liii. 3.
5. Koran xxvi. 88.
6. Cp. Nicom. Ethics, x., iv. 6.
7. Compare Gulshan i Raz, I. 624. Ecstatic words and states are the
offspring of communion with God.

The Faqir and the Hidden Treasure.
Notwithstanding the clear evidence of God's bounty, engendering these
spiritual states in men, philosophers and learned men, wise in their own
conceit, obstinately shut their eyes to it, and look afar off for what is
really close to them, so that they incur the penalty of "being branded on
the nostrils," 1 adjudged against unbelievers. This is illustrated by the
story of a poor Faqir who prayed to God that he might be fed without being
obliged to work for his food. A divine voice came to him in his sleep and
directed him to go to the house of a certain scribe and take a certain
writing that he should find there. He did so, and on reading the writing
found that it contained directions for finding a hidden treasure. The
directions were as follows: "Go outside the city to the dome which covers
the tomb of the martyr; turn your back to the tomb and your face towards
Mecca, place an arrow in your bow, and where the arrow falls there dig for
the treasure." But before the Faqir had time to commence the search the
rumor of the writing and its contents had reached the king, who at once sent
and took it away from the Faqir, and began to search for the treasure on his
own account. After shooting many arrows and digging in all directions the
king failed to find the treasure, and got weary of searching, and returned
the writing to the Faqir. Then the Faqir tried what he could do, but failed
altogether to hit the spot where the treasure was buried. At last,
despairing of success by his own unaided efforts, he cast his care upon God,
and implored the divine assistance. Then a voice from heaven came to him,
saying, "You were directed to fix an arrow on your bow, but not to draw your
bow with all your might, as you have been doing. Shoot as gently as
possible, that the arrow may fall close to you, for the hidden treasure is
indeed 'nearer to you than your neck-vein.' "2 Men overlook the spiritual
treasures close to them, and for this reason it is that prophets have no
honor in their own countries, as is illustrated by the cases of the saint
Abu-'l-Hasan Khirqani and the Prophet Hud or Heber.
God rules men by alternations of hope and fear.
This sad Faqir too put up his cries for aid,
And bore off the ball of acceptance from the field.
But at times he distrusted the efficacy of his prayers,
On account of the delay in answering them.
Again, hope of the mercy of the Lord
Arose in his heart as an earnest of rejoicing.
When he was hopeless and ceasing to pray in weariness
He heard from God the word "Ascend!"
God is an Abaser and an Exalter
Without these two processes nothing comes into being.
Behold the abasement of earth and uplifting of heaven;
Without these two heaven would not revolve, O man!
The abasement and exaltation of earth is otherwise,
Half the year is barren, half green and verdant.
The abasement and exaltation of weary time
Is otherwise again, half day and half night.
The abasement and exaltation of this compound body
Is now health and now grievous sickness.
Know all the conditions of the world are in this wise,
Drought, famine, peace, war, and trials.
This world flies, as it were, with these two wings;
Through these all souls are homes of hope and fear;
So that the world keeps trembling like leaves,
In the cold and hot winds of death and resurrection.
Till tbe jar of pure wine of our 'Isa (Unity)
Shall supersede the jar of many-colored wine (plurality),
For that world (of unity) is as a saltpan;
Whatever enters it loses its varied hues.
On the text, "Verily I am about to place a Khalifa or Vicegerent on earth"
Whereas the aim and will of the Merciful God
Inclined to the revelation and manifestation of Himself,
And one opposite cannot be shown but by its opposite,
And that Unique King of kings has no opposite or peer, 4
Therefore that Lord of the heart set up a Khalifa,
To serve as a mirror to reflect His own sovereignty.
Therefore He gave him unlimited purity and light,
And on the other side He set darkness opposing the light. 5
God set up two standards, a white and a black one,
The one Adam and the other Iblis;
And between these two mighty armies
Ensued war and battle and all we have witnessed.
Thus, too, in the second generation lived pure Abel;
Cain was the opposite of his pure light.
In like manner these two standards of right and wrong
Were borne aloft till the age of Nimrod.
Nimrod was the opponent and adversary of Abraham,
And their opposing camps warred and fought one another.
When God grew weary of the length of this war,
His fire was appointed to arbitrate between them.
He commanded fire and its flaming torment
To settle the matter in dispute between them.
Age after age these two parties contended,
Even till the time of Pharaoh and gentle Moses.
Between these two the war was waged for years,
And when it passed all bounds and affliction increased
God made the water of the Nile a judge between them,
That the one who deserved preeminence should endure.
In like manner it went on till the time of Mustafa
And Abu Jahl, that prince of iniquity.
Likewise did God ordain a punishment for the Thamud,
Namely, an earthquake which destroyed their lives.
Likewise a punishment for the Adites,
Namely, a swiftly rising and violent wind.
Likewise God ordained acute punishment for Qarun;
For the earth concealed wrath under its mildness,
Till all its mildness was converted into wrath,
And it swallowed up Qarun and his wealth in its depth.
So with the mouthful which nourishes your body
And wards off the darts of hunger like a cuirass,
When God instils wrath into this mouthful of bread,
That same bread will choke you like a halter.
This same garment which protects you from the cold,
God may give it the quality of intense cold,
So that this warm vest may become to your body
Cold as ice and biting as frost;
So that you will cast off these furs and silks,
And seek for a refuge from cold with cold itself.
You have only one eye, not two (for these two possibilities).
You have forgotten the story of the "shadowing cloud." 6
God's command came to city and village,
And to house and wall, saying, "Afford no shade!
Ward not off the pouring rain and the sun's heat;"
Till those men hasted to listen to the prophet Shu'aib,
Saying, 'O king, have pity; most of us are dead!'
But read the rest of the tale in the commentaries.
When that Omnipotent hand made the staff a serpent,
If you have reason, that portent should suffice.
You have sight indeed, but fail to mark carefully;
Your eyes are dimmed and closed with fat.
The heavenly treasure lies "nearer to us than our neck-vein".
The Faqir was in this state when a divine voice came,
And God thus solved his difficulties,
Saying, "The voice told you to place an arrow on the bow,
It did not bid you draw the bowstring to the utmost;
It did not bid you draw the bow with all your might;
It said, 'Adjust an arrow,' not 'Draw the bow fully.'
You elevated the bow to excess,
You magnified unduly the bowman's art,
Go! abandon this strong bowmanship,
Fix an arrow on the string, but make it not fly far.
When it falls, dig in that spot and search,
Abandon force and seek the treasure with humility."
God is "what is nearer to you than your neck-vein,"
You have cast the arrow of speculation afar off.
O you, who have made ready your bow and arrows,
The game is close to you, and you shoot too far off.
The further a man shoots, the further off he is,
And the more removed from the treasure he seeks.
The philosopher kills himself with thinking,
Tell him that his back is turned to that treasure;
Tell him that the more he runs to and fro,
The Almighty says, "Make efforts in our ways," 7
Not "Make efforts away from us," O restless one.
Like Canaan, who went away, from shame to follow Noah,
Up to the top of that lofty mountain,
The more he sought safety on that mountain,
The further was he removed from the safe asylum.
So this Faqir, in search of that hidden treasure,
Day after day drew his bow stronger and stronger;
And the harder he drew his bow,
The further was he from the seat of that treasure.
This parable applies to all times,
For the soul of the ignorant is pledged to misfortune.
Because the ignorant man is ashamed of a master,
Perforce he goes and opens a new school for himself.
That school is higher than your true master, O beloved,
And hard of access, and full of scorpions and snakes.
Straightway overthrow it, and turn back again
To the green garden and sweet watered meadows.
Not like Canaan, who, through pride and ignorance,
Sought his ark of safety on a protecting mountain.
His far-shooting learning veiled his eyes,
While his heart's desire was all the while in his grasp.
Ah! oftentimes have learning and genius and wit
Proved to the traveler to be Ghouls and highwaymen!
"The majority of those in Paradise are the simple," 8
Who have escaped the snares of philosophy.
Strip yourself bare of overweening intellect,
That grace may ever be shed upon you from above.
Cleverness is the opposite of humility and submission,
Quit cleverness, and consort with simple-mindedness!
1. Koran lxviii. 16.
2. Koran l. 15.
3. Koran ii. 28.
4. Because, as Sir T. Browne says, "God is all things."
5. See Gulshan i Raz, I. 265, and note.
6. Koran xxvi. 189. The cloud emitted heat instead of rain, to punish those
who disregarded Shu'aib, or Jethro.
7. Koran xxix. 69.
8. A Hadis. Cp. 1 Cor. i. 25, 26.

The Three Travelers.
A Mosalman was traveling with two unbelievers, a Jew and a Christian. Like
wisdom linked with the flesh and the devil. God was "nigh unto His faithful
servant," 1 and when the first stage was completed He caused a present of
sweetmeats to be laid before the travelers. As the Jew and the Christian had
already eaten their evening meal when the sweetmeats arrived, they proposed
to lay them aside till the morrow; but the Mosalman, who was keeping fast,
and therefore could not eat before nightfall, proposed to eat them that
night. To this the other two refused to consent, alleging that the Mosalman
wanted to eat the whole of the sweetmeats himself. Then the Mosalman
proposed to divide them into three portions, so that each might eat his own
portion when he pleased; but this also was objected to by the others, who
quoted the proverb, "The divider is in hell" The Mosalman explained to them
that this proverb meant the man who divides his allegiance between God and
lust; but they still refused to give way, and the Mosalman therefore
submitted, and lay down to sleep in the endurance of the pangs of hunger.
Next morning, when they awoke, it was agreed between them that each should
relate his dreams, and that the sweetmeats should be awarded to him whose
dream was the best. The Jew said that he had dreamed that Moses had carried
him to the top of Mount Sinai, and shown him marvelous visions of the glory
of heaven and the angels. The Christian said he had dreamed that 'Isa had
carried him up to the fourth heaven and shown him all the glories of the
heavens. Finally the Mosalman said that the Prophet Muhammad had appeared to
him in person, and after commending him for his piety in saying his prayers
and keeping fast so strictly on the previous night, had commanded him to eat
up those divinely provided sweetmeats as a reward, and he had accordingly
done so. The Jew and the Christian were at first annoyed with him for thus
stealing a march upon them; but on his pointing out that he had no option
but to obey the Prophet's commands, they admitted that he had done right,
and that his dream was the best, as he had been awake, while they were
asleep. The moral is, that the divine treasure is revealed as an immediate
intuition to those who seek it with prayer and humble obedience, and not to
those who seek to infer and deduce its nature and quality from the lofty
abstractions of philosophy.
Lofty philosophical speculation does not lead to the knowledge of God.
The Mosalman said, "O my friends,
My lord, the Prophet Muhammad, appeared to me
And said, 'The Jew has hurried to the top of Sinai,
And plays a game of love with God's interlocutor;
The Christian has been carried by 'Isa, Lord of bliss
Up to the summit of the fourth heaven
Thou who art left behind and hast endured anguish,
Arise quickly and eat the sweetmeats and confections!
Those two clever and learned men have ascended,
And read their titles of dignity and exaltation;
Those two exalted ones have found exalted science,
And rivaled the very angels in intellect;
O humble and simple and despised one,
Arise and eat of the banquet of the divine sweets!"
They said to him, "Then you have been gluttonous;
Well indeed! you have eaten all the sweets!"
He answered, "When my sovereign lord commanded me,
Who am I that I should abstain from obeying?
Would you, O Jew, resist the commands of Moses
If he bade you do something, either pleasant or not?
Would you, O Christian, rebel against 'Isa's commands,
Whether those commands were agreeable or the reverse?
How could I rebel against the 'Glory of the prophets'?
Nay, I ate the sweets, and am now happy."
They replied, "By Allah, you have seen a true vision;
Your vision is better than a hundred like ours.
Your dream was seen by you when awake, O happy one,
For it was seen to be real by your being awake."
Quit excessive speculation and inordinate science,
'Tis service of God and good conduct that gains its end.
'Tis for this that God created us,
"We created not mankind save to worship us" 2
What profit did his science bring to Samiri? 3
His science excluded him from God's portals.
Consider what Qarun gained by his alchemy;
He was swallowed up in the depths of the earth.
Abu-l Jahl, again, what gained he from his wit
Save to be hurled head-foremost into hell for infidelity?
Know real science is seeing the fire directly,
Not mere talk, inferring the fire from the smoke.
Your scientific proofs are more offensive to the wise
Than the urine and breath whence a physician infers.
If these be your only proofs, O son,
Smell foul breath and inspect urine like physicians.
Such proofs are as the staff of a blind man,
Which prove only the blindness of the holder.
All your outcry and pompous claims and bustle
Only say, "I cannot see, hold me excused!"
This is illustrated be an anecdote of a peasant who, hearing a proclamation
issued by the Prince of Tirmid, to the effect that a large reward would be
given to him who should take a message to Samarcaud in the space of four
days, hurried to Tirmid by relays of post-horses in the utmost haste, and
threw the whole city into alarm, as the people thought that his extreme
haste and bustle must portend the approach of an enemy or some other
calamity. But when he was admitted to the presence of the prince, all he had
to say was, that he had hurried to inform him that he could not go to
Samarcand so quickly. The prince was very angry with him for making all this
disturbance about nothing, and threatened to punish him.
The uses of chastisements.
He said, "Alms of mercy repel calamity, 4
Alms cure thy sickness, O son
'Tis not charitable to burn up the poor,
Or to put out the eyes of the meek."
The prince replied, "Kindness is good in its place,
Provided you do kindness in its proper place.
If at chess you put the king in the rook's place
That is wrong; and so if you put the knight in the king's,
The law prescribes both rewards and chastisements.
The king's place is the throne, the horse's the gate.
What is justice but putting each in his place?
What injustice but putting each in what is not his place?
Nothing is vain of all that God has created,
Whether vengeance or mercy, or plain dealing or snares.
Not one of all these is good absolutely,
Nor is any one of them absolutely bad.
Each is harmful or beneficial according to its place,
Wherefore knowledge of these points is proper and useful.
Ah! many are the chastisements sent to the poor
Which are more beneficial to him than bread and sweets;
Because sweets out of season excite biliousness,
While blows make him pure from impurity.
Strike the poor man timely blows,
Which may save him from being beheaded later."
The peasant, in reply, urged the prince not to be over hasty in punishing
him, but to take counsel with suitable advisers, as enjoined in various
texts, 5 and in the Hadis prohibiting monkery, and warned him that if he
shunned the advice and society of his equals he would assuredly be led
astray by wretched companions. 6 In illustration of this a story is told of
a mouse who conceived a great affection for a frog living in a neighboring
pond. 7 That he might be able to communicate with his friend at all times,
he fastened a string to the frog's leg, and the other end of it to his own.
The proverb says, "Occasional intermission of visits augments love," 8 but
ardent lovers desire to be in communication with the object of their love
without intermission. The frog was at first unwilling to enter into such
close relations with an animal of another species, but at last allowed
himself to be persuaded to do so, against his better judgment. Shortly
afterwards a raven swooped down on the mouse and carried him off, and the
frog, being fastened to the mouse, was dragged off and destroyed along with
it. The raven's friends said to him, "How is it you managed to catch an
animal that lives in the water?" and he replied, "Because it was so silly as
to consort with one of another species that lived on dry land."
Comparison of the body to the mouse, and the soul to the frog.
The two friends discussed the matter long,
And after discussion this plan was settled,
That they should fetch a long string,
By means of which to communicate with one another.
The mouse said, "One end must be tied to your leg,
And the other end to the leg of me, your double,
That by this contrivance we two may be united,
And be mingled together like soul and body."
Body is like a string tied to sod's foot,
That string drags soul down to earth.
The soul is the frog in the water of ecstatic bliss;
Escaping from the mouse of the body, it is in bliss.
The mouse of the body drags it back with that string;
Ah! what sorrow it tastes through being dragged back
If it were not dragged down by that insolent mouse,
The frog would remain at peace in its water.
On the last day, when you shall awake from sleep,
You will learn the rest of this from the Sun of truth!
In illustration of the thesis that the sense which perceives the unseen and
spiritual world is superior to the other senses, and is exempt from death
and decay, the poet tells an anecdote of Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni and some
robbers. One night, when walking about the city alone, he fell in with a
band of robbers. He told them he was one of them, and proposed that each
should tell his own special talent. Accordingly one said he could hear what
the dogs said when they barked; another that his sight was so good that when
he saw a man at night he could recognize him without fail next day; another
said his talent lay in the strength of his arms, whereby he dug holes
through the walls of houses another said he could divine by his sense of
smell where gold was hidden; another said his wrist was so strong that he
could throw a rope farther than any one. At last it came to the turn of the
king, and he told them that his talent lay in his beard, for when he wagged
it he could deliver criminals from the executioner. The robbers then went to
the king's palace, and, each of them co-operating by the exercise of his
peculiar talent, they broke into it, and plundered a large sum of money. The
king, after witnessing the burglary, withdrew from them secretly, and,
having summoned his Vazir, gave orders for their apprehension. No sooner
were the robbers brought before the king than the one whose talent lay in
recognizing by day those whom he had seen in the darkness of night at once
knew him, and said to the others, "This is the man who said his talent lay
in his beard!" Thus the only one whose talent profited him at the time of
need was he who could recognize by day what he had previously seen by night;
for he appealed to the king to exercise his talent of deliverance, and the
king listened to his entreaty, and delivered him from the executioner.
He whose eyes discern God in the world is safe from destruction.
He who, when he had once seen a person at night,
Recognized him without fail when he saw him by day,
Saw the king upon the throne, and straightway cried,
"This was he who accompanied us on our nightly walk;
This is he whose beard possessed such rare talent;
Our arrest is due to his sagacity."
He added, "'Yea, he was with you,' 9 this great king;
He beheld our actions and heard our secrets.
My eyes guided me to recognize that king at night,
And dwelt lovingly on his face, like the moon at night.
Now, therefore, I will implore his grace for myself,
For he will never avert his face from him that knew him."
Know the eye of the ' Knower is a safeguard in both worlds,
For therein ye will find a very Bahram to aid you.
For this cause Muhammad was the intercessor for faults,
Because his eye 'did not wander' 10 from the King of kings.
In the night of this world, when the sun is hidden,
He beheld God, and placed his hopes on Him.
His eyes were anointed with the words, ' We opened thy heart,' 11
He beheld what Gabriel himself had not power to see." 12
The story of the frog is concluded by the lamentations of the frog over his
folly in consorting with an animal of a different genus to his own, on which
Reason warns him that homogeneity lies in spirit, not in outward form; and
this is illustrated by an anecdote of a man named 'Abdu'l Ghaus, who was the
son of a fairy mother, and consequently homogeneous with the fairies, though
only an ordinary man to outward appearance.
1. Koran ii. 182.
2. Koran ii. 56.
3. Samiri, the maker of the golden calf. Qarun Korah.
4. Freytag Arabum Proverbia, iii. 277.
5. Koran lxvii. 22, iii. 155, xlii. 36.
6. Koran xliii. 37.
7. Anvari Suhaili, Chap. vii. Story III.
8. Freytag, Arabum Proverbia, i. 287.
9. Koran lvii. 4.
10. Koran liii. 17.
11. Koran xciv. 1.
12. Gulshan i Raz, I. 120.

The Man who received a Pension from the Prefect of Tabriz.
These reflections on the nothingness of outward form compared to spirit lead
the poet to the corollary that often men whose outward forms are buried in
the grave are greater benefactors to the poor and helpless than men still
living in the body. This is illustrated by the story of the man who was
maintained by the Prefect of Tabriz. This man incurred heavy debts on the
credit of his pension, even as the Imam Ja'far Sadiq was able to capture a
strong fort single-handed through the power of God assisting him. When the
creditors became pressing the man journeyed to Tabriz to seek further aid;
but on arriving there he found the Prefect was dead. On learning this he was
much cast down, but eventually recognized that he had erred in looking to a
creature instead of his Creator for aid, according to the text, "The
infidels equalize others with their Lord." 1 This obliquity of spiritual
sight, causing him to see a mere human benefactor, where the real benefactor
was God alone, is illustrated by anecdotes of a man buying bread at Kashan,
of Sultan Khwarazm Shah deluded into disliking a fine horse by the
interested advice of his Vazir, and of Joseph, who when imprisoned by
Pharaoh was induced to trust for deliverance to the intercession of the
chief butler rather than to God alone, for which cause "he remained several
years in prison." 2 A charitable person of Tabriz endeavoured to raise funds
for the poor man, and appealed to the citizens to aid him, but only
succeeded in collecting a very small sum. He then visited the Prefect's
tomb, and implored assistance from him; and the same night the Prefect
appeared to him in a dream, and gave him directions where to find a great
treasure, and directed him to make over this treasure to the poor man. Thus
the dead Prefect proved a more liberal benefactor than the citizens of
Tabriz who were still living.
The poor man's regrets for having placed his trust in man and not in God.
When he recovered himself he said, "O God,
I have sinned in looking for aid to a creature!
Although the Prefect showed great liberality,
It was in no wise equal to Thy bounty.
He gave me a cap, but Thou my head full of sense;
He gave me a garment, but Thou my tall form.
He gave me gold, but Thou my hand which counts it;
He gave me a horse, but Thou my reason to guide it;
He gave me a lamp, but Thou my lucid eyes;
He gave me sweetmeats, but Thou my appetite for them;
He gave me a pension, but Thou my life and being;
His gift was gold, but Thine true blessings;
He gave me a house, but Thou heaven and earth;
In Thy house he and a hundred like him are nourished.
The gold was of Thy providing, he did not create it;
The bread of Thy providing, and furnished to him by Thee.
Thou also didst give him his liberality,
For thereby Thou didst augment his happiness.
I made him my Qibla, and directed my prayers to him;
I turned away my eyes from Thee, the Qibla-maker!
Where was he when the Supreme Dispenser of faith
Sowed reason in the water and clay of man,
And drew forth from Not-being this heavenly dome,
And spread out the carpet of the earth?
Of the stars He made torches to illumine the sky,
And of the four elements locks with keys (of reason).
Ah! many are the buildings visible and invisible
Which God has made between heaven's dome and earth.
Man is the astrolabe of those exalted attributes,
The attribute of man is to manifest God's signs.
Whatever is seen in man is the reflection of God,
Even as the reflection of the moon in water."
Say not two, know not two, call not on two!
Know the slave is obliterated in his lord!
So the lord is obliterated in God that created him
Yea, lost and dead and buried in his Creator!
When you regard this lord as separate from God,
You annihilate at once text and paraphrase.
With eyes and heart look beyond mere water and clay,
God alone is the Qibla; regard not two Qiblas!
If you regard two you lose the benefit of both;
A spark falls on the tinder and the tinder vanishes!
Joseph kept in prison a long time for having placed his hopes of release in
man and not in God.
In like manner Joseph, in the prison,
With humble and earnest supplications
Begged aid, saying, "When you are released,
And are occupied with your ministrations to the king,
Remember me, and entreat the king
To release rue too from this prison."
How can one prisoner fettered in the snare
Procure release for a fellow prisoner?
The people of the world are all prisoners,
Awaiting death on the stake of annihilation;
Except one or two rare exceptions,
Whose bodies are in prison but their souls in heaven.
Afterwards, because Joseph had looked to man for aid,
He remained in prison for many years.
The Devil caused the man to forget Joseph,
And blotted Joseph's words from his remembrance;
And on account of this fault of that holy man
God left him in the prison for many years.
1. Koran vi. 1.
2. Koran xii. 42.
3. Koran xii. 42.

The King and his Three Sons.
A certain king had three sons, who were the light of his eyes, and, as it
were, a fountain whence the palm tree of his heart drank the water of bliss.
One day he called his sons before him and commanded them to travel through
his realm, and to inspect the behavior of the governors and the state of the
administration; and he strictly charged them not to go near a particular
fort which he named. But, according to the saying, "Man hankers after what
is forbidden," the three princes disobeyed their father, and, before going
anywhere else, proceeded to visit this fort. The result was, that they fell
into calamities, and had occasion to repeat the text, "Had we but hearkened
or understood, we had not been among the dwellers in the flame." 1 The fort
was full of pictures, images and forms, and amongst them was a portrait of a
beautiful damsel, the daughter of the King of China, which made such a deep
impression on the three princes that they all became distracted with love
and determined to journey to the court of the King of China and sue for the
hand of his daughter.
The significance of forms. 2
Be not intoxicated with these goblets of forms,
Lest you become a maker and worshipper of idols.
Pass by these cups full of forms, linger not;
There is wine in the cups, but it proceeds not from them.
Look to the Giver of the wine with open mouth;
When His wine comes, is not cup too small to hold it?
O Adam, seek the reality of my love,
Quit the mere husk and form of the wheat.
When sand was made meal for "The Friend of God," 3
Know, O master, the form of wheat was dispensed with.
Form proceeds from the world that is without form,
Even as smoke arises from fire.
The Divine art without form designs forms (ideals), 4
Those forms fashion bodies with senses and instruments.
Whatever the form, it fashions in its own likeness
Those bodies either to good or to evil.
If the form be blessing, the man is thankful;
If it be suffering, he is patient;
If it be cherishing, he is cheerful;
If it be bruising, he is full of lamentation!
Since all these forms are slaves of Him without form,
Why do they deny their Lord and Master?
They exist only through Him that is without form;
What, then, means their disavowal of their Sustainer?
This very denial of Him proceeds from Him,
This act is naught but a reflection from Himself!
The forms of the walls and roofs of houses
Know to be shadows of the architect's thought;
Although stones and planks and bricks
Find no entrance into the sanctuary of thought,
Verily the Absolute Agent is without form,
Form is only a tool in His hands.
Sometimes that Formless One of His mercy
Shows His face to His forms from behind the veil of Not-being,
That every form may derive aid therefrom,
From its perfect beauty and power.
Again, when that Formless One hides His face,
Those forms set forth their needs.
If one form sought perfection from another form,
That would be the height of error.
Why then, O simpleton, do you set forth your needs
To one who is as needy as yourself?
Since forms are slaves, apply them not to God,
Seek not to use a form as a similitude of God. 5
Seek Him with humbleness and self-abasement,
For thought yields naught but forms of thought.
Still, if you are unable to dispense with forms,
Those occurring independently of your thought are best. 6
The "Truth," which is our real self, lies hidden within our phenomenal and
visible self, and the Prophets reveal it to us.
"Now have we seen what the king saw at the first,
When that Incomparable One adjured us."
The prophets have many claims to our gratitude,
Because they forewarn us of our ultimate lot,
Saying, "What ye sow will yield only thorns;
If ye fly that way, ye will fly astray.
Take seed of us to yield you a good harvest,
Fly with our wings to hit the mark with your arrow.
Now ye know not the truth and nature of the 'Truth,' 7
But at the last ye will cry, 'That was the "Truth."'
The Truth is yourself, but not your mere bodily self,
Your real self is higher than 'you' and 'me.'
This visible 'you' which you fancy to be yourself
Is limited in place, the real 'you' is not limited.
Why, O pearl, linger you trembling in your shell?
Esteem not yourself mere sugar-cane, but real sugar.
This outward 'you' is foreign to your real ' you;'
Cling to your real self, quit this dual self.
Your last self attains to your first (real) self
Only through your attending earnestly to that union.
Your real self lies hid beneath your outward self,
For 'I am the servant of him who looks into himself.' " 8
"What a youth sees only when reflected in a glass,
Our wise old fathers saw long ago though hid in stones.
But we disobeyed the advice of our father,
And rebelled against his affectionate counsels.
We made light of the king's exhortations,
And slighted his matchless intimations.
Now we have all fallen into the ditch,
Wounded and crushed in this fatal struggle.
We relied on our own reason and discernment,
And for that cause have fallen into this calamity.
We fancied ourselves free from defects of sight,
Even as those affected by color-blindness.
Now at last our hidden disease has been revealed,
After we have been involved in these calamities."
"The shadow of a guide is better than directions to God,
To be satisfied is better than a hundred nice dishes.
A seeing eye is better than a hundred walking-sticks,
Eye discerns jewels from mere pebbles."
The princes ascertained the name of the lady depicted in the fort from an
old Shaikh, who warned them of the perils they would encounter on their
journey to China, and told them that the King of China would not bestow his
favor on those who tried to gain it by tricks and clever stratagems, but
solely on those who were prepared to yield up their lives to him, according
to the saying, "Die before you die." This is illustrated by an anecdote of a
Chief of Bokhara, who made it a rule never to bestow his bounty on beggars
who asked for it, but only on those who awaited his pleasure in silence. A
certain Faqir tried many stratagems to evade this rule, but his craft was at
once seen through by the Chief, and turned to his own confusion. The thesis
that the unbought free grace of God is superior to any blessing obtainable
by human exertion and contrivance is further illustrated by an absurd
anecdote of two youths, one of whom trusted for protection to his own
contrivance, and found it a broken reed. The Prophet said, "Two there are
who are never satisfied the lover of the world and the lover of knowledge;"
and he who loves knowledge will continue to trust in his knowledge, in spite
of all exhortations and experience. But the eldest prince advised his
brothers to risk the perils and persevere in the journey, reminding them
that "Patience is the key of joy." Accordingly they abandoned their country
and their parents, like Ibrahim Adham, who renounced the throne of Balkh,
and like the old Arabian king Amru'l Qais, who fled from the pursuit of his
female adorers to seek the Spiritual Beloved in a far country.
How the princes discoursed with one another in figurative language
concerning their beloved mistress.
They told their secrets to one another in dark sayings,
Speaking beneath their breath in fear and trembling.
None but God was privy to their secrets,
None but Heaven was partner in their sighs.
Yea, they used technical expressions one to another,
And possessed intelligence to extract the sense.
The vulgar learn the words of this "language of birds," 9
And make boast of their mastery thereof;
But these words are only the outward form of the language,
The "raw" man is ignorant of the birds' meaning.
He is the true Solomon who knows the birds' language,
A demon, though he usurp his kingdom, is quite another.
The demon has taken upon him the form of Solomon,
His knowledge is fraud, not "what we have been taught."
When Solomon was blessed with inspiration from God,
He learned birds' language from "what we were taught."
But thou art only a bird of the air; understand then
That thou hast never seen the true spiritual birds!
The nest of the Simurgh is beyond Mount Qaf, 10
Not every thought can attain thereto;
Save thoughts which catch a glimpse thereof,
And after the vision are again shut off.
Yet not all shut off, rather intermitted for a wise end,
For the blessing abides, though shut off and hidden!
In order to preserve that body which is as a soul,
The Sun is veiled for a while behind a cloud;
In order not to melt that soul-like body,
The Sun withdraws itself as from ice.
For thy soul's sake seek counsel of these inspired ones. 11
Ah! rob not their words of their technical meanings!
Zulaikha applied to Yusuf the names of all things,
Beginning with wild rue and ending with frankincense.
She veiled his name under all other names,
And imparted her secret meaning to her confidants.
When she said, "The wax is melted by the fire,"
She meant, "My lover is wroth with me."
So when she said, "See, the moon is risen!"
Or, "Lo! the willow-bough is putting forth leaves;"
Or if she said, "The leaves quiver in the wind,"
Or, "The wild rue yields perfume as it burns;"
Or if she said, "The rose tells her tale to the Bulbul,"
Or, "The king sings his love-strain;"
Or if she said, "Ah! what a blessed lot!"
Or, "Who hath disturbed my heart's repose?"
Or if she said, "The water-carrier hath brought water,"
Or, "Lo! the sun emerges from the clouds;"
Or if she said, "Last night the victuals were boiled,"
Or, "The food was perfectly cooked;"
Or if she said, "My bread is without savor"
Or, "The heavens are revolving the wrong way;
Or if she said, "My head aches with pain,"
Or, "My headache is now relieved;"
If she gave thanks, 'twas for being united to Yusuf;
If she wailed, 'twas that she was separated from him.
Though she gave vent to thousands of names,
Her meaning and purport was only Yusuf;
Was she an hungred, when she pronounced his name,
She became filled and cheered by his nourishment.
Her thirst was quenched by Yusuf's name,
His name was spiritual water to her soul.
Was she in pain, by pronouncing his mighty name
At once her pain was turned into joy.
In the cold it was a warm garment;
Her lover's name accomplished all this through love.
Strangers may pronounce the "pure name" of God,
Yet it effects no such marvels, for they lack love.
All that 'Isa accomplished by the name of Jehovah,
Zulaikha attained through the name "Yusuf."
When the soul is intimately united with God,
To name the one is the same as naming the other.
Zulaikha was empty of self and filled with love of Yusuf,
And there flowed out of her jar what it contained.
The scent of the saffron of union made her smile,
The stench of the onion of separation made her weep.
Each to have in his heart a hundred meanings,
Such is not the creed of true love and devotion.
"The Friend" is to the lover as day to the sun,
The material sun is a veil over the face of the real day.
Whoso distinguishes not the veil from "The Friend's" face
Is a worshipper of the sun; of such a one beware!
"The Friend" is the real day, and daily food of lovers,
The heart and the heart's torment of His lovers.
After enduring many toils and misfortunes the three princes at last arrived
in the metropolis of China, and thereupon the eldest prince expressed his
intention of presenting himself before the king, as he could wait no longer.
His brothers tried to dissuade him from risking his life, pointing out that
if he acted on blind impulse and vain conceit he would surely go astray, for
"a conceit hath naught of truth;" 12 and they further urged him to listen to
the counsels of the Pir, or Spiritual Director. But the eldest brother
refused to be dissuaded from his purpose, saying he would no longer hide his
passion for his beloved, like one who beats a drum under a blanket, but
would proclaim it openly, and take the risk of whatever might ensue. He
added that he was convinced that he should obtain his desire in some way or
other, if not in the way that he expected; according to the text, "Whoso
feareth God, to him will he grant a prosperous issue, and will provide for
him in a way he reckoned not." 13 Seekers after God fancy that He is far
from them, and that they must travel far to reach Him; but these are both
erroneous suppositions; and just as arithmeticians work out true answers to
their problems by the "Method of Errors," 14 so must the seekers of God from
these errors work out the conviction that God is very nigh to them that call
upon Him faithfully. To illustrate this an anecdote is told of a man of
Baghdad who was in great distress, and who, after calling on God for aid,
dreamt that a great treasure lay hid in a certain spot in Egypt. He
accordingly journeyed to Egypt, and there fell into the hands of the patrol,
who arrested him, and beat him severely on suspicion of being a thief.
Calling to mind the proverb that "falsehood is a mischief but truth a
remedy," 15 he determined to confess the true reason of his coming to Egypt,
and accordingly told them all the particulars of his dream. On hearing them
they believed him, and one of them said, "You must be a fool to journey all
this distance merely on the faith of a dream. I myself have many times
dreamt of a treasure lying hid in a certain spot in Baghdad, but was never
foolish enough to go there." Now the spot in Baghdad named by this person
was none other than the house of the poor man of Baghdad, and he straightway
returned home, and there found the treasure. And he gave thanks, and
recognized how "God causes ease to follow troubles," 16 and how "Men hate
what is good for them," 17 and how God delays the answer to prayer, and
allows men to remain poor and hungry for a season, in order to make them
call upon Him, even as the Prophet said, "My servant is a lute which sounds
best when it is empty."
Why the answer to prayer is delayed.
Ah! many earnest suppliants wail forth prayers,
Till the smoke of their wailing rises to heaven;
Yea, the perfume of the incense of sinners' groans
Mounts up above the lofty roof of heaven.
Then the angels supplicate God, saying,
"O Thou that hearest prayer and relievest pain,
Thy faithful slave is bowing down before Thee.
He knows of none on whom to rely save Thee;
Thou bestowest favors on the helpless.
Every suppliant obtains his desire from Thee."
God makes answer, "The delay in granting his prayer
Is intended to benefit him, not to harm him.
His pressing need draws him from his negligence to me;
Yea, drags him by the hair into my courts.
If I at once remove his need he will go away,
And will be destroyed in his idle sports.
Though he is wailing with heartfelt cry of 'O Aider!'
Bid him wail on with broken heart and contrite breast.
His voice sounds sweet in my ears,
And his wailing and cries of' O God!'
In this way by supplication and lamentation
He prevails with me altogether."
It is on account of their sweet voices
That choice parrots and nightingales are jailed in cages.
Ugly owls and crows 18 are never jailed in cages;
Such a thing was never heard of in history.
The disappointments of the pious, be sure,
Are appointed for this wise purpose.
The eldest brother then delayed no longer, but rushed into the presence of
the King and kissed his feet. The King, like a good shepherd, was well aware
of the troubles and cravings of his sheep. He knew that the prince had
abjured earthly rank and dignity through love for his daughter, even as a
Sufi casts away his robe when overpowered by ecstatic rapture. The only
reason why the prince had lagged behind in the race and not presented
himself to the King before was that hitherto he had lacked the "inner eye"
or spiritual sense which discerns spiritual verities, and had been
consequently blind to the King's perfections. They who lack this inner
spiritual sense can no more appreciate spiritual pleasures than a man
lacking the sense of smell can enjoy the perfume of flowers, or a eunuch the
society of fair women. But his eyes had now been opened by the King's grace,
and he had escaped from the bondage of worldly lusts and illusions, and,
taught by experience, had resolved never again to be led captive by them.
This is illustrated by the anecdote of the Qazi who was beguiled by the wife
of a dwarf. The dwarf and his wife were very poor, and one day the dwarf
said to his wife, "God has given you arched brows and arrowy glances and all
manner of witchery; go and ensnare some rich man, so that we may extract
money from him!" So the woman went to the court of the Qazi, pretending to
have a grievance; and when she saw the Qazi she beguiled him, and induced
him to pay her a visit at night. While the Qazi was sitting with her the
dwarf returned home and knocked violently at the door, and the Qazi, in a
great fright, hid himself in a large chest. The dwarf at once fetched a
porter, and told him to take the chest to the bazar and sell it. On the way
to the bazar the Qazi cried out to the porter to fetch the Deputy; and when
the Deputy came he redeemed the chest for one hundred Dinars, and thus the
Qazi escaped. Next year the woman went to the court and tried to seduce the
Qazi a second time; but he said, "Begone; I have escaped from your toils
once, and will not fall into them again. The action of the Deputy in freeing
the Qazi reminds the poet of the saying of the Prophet, "Of him, of whom I
am the master, 'Ali also is master," and is therefore able to free him from
The eldest prince at last fell sick of hope deferred, and gave up the ghost.
But though he failed to obtain the King's daughter, the object of his
earthly attachment, he obtained union with the King, the real spiritual
object of his love, and the eternal fruition of dwelling in Him.
The joys of union with the Spiritual Beloved are inexpressible in speech.
In short, the King cherished him lovingly,
And he like a moon waned in that sun.
That waning of lovers makes them wax stronger,
Just as the moon waxes brighter after waning.
Ordinary sick persons crave a remedy for sickness
But the lovesick one cries, "Increase my waning!
I have never tasted wine sweeter than this poison,
No health can be sweeter than this sickness!
No devotion is better than this sin (of love),
Years are as a moment compared to this moment!"
Long time he dwelt with the King in this manner,
With burning heart, as a lively sacrifice.
Thus his life passed, yet he gained not the union He wished.
Patient waiting consumed him, his soul could not bear it;
He dragged on life with pain and gnashing of teeth.
At last life ended before he had attained his desire.
The form of his earthly Beloved was hidden from him;
He departed, and found union with his Spiritual Beloved.
Then he said, "Though she lacks clothes of silk and wool,
'Tis sweeter to embrace her without those veils.
I have become naked of the body and its illusions,
I am admitted into the most intimate union."
The story admits of being told up to this point,
Bat what follows is hidden and inexpressible in words.
If you should speak and try a hundred ways to express it,
'Tis useless; the mystery becomes no clearer.
You can ride on saddle and horse up to the sea-coast,
But then you must use a horse of wood (i.e., a boat).
A horse of wood is useless on dry land,
It is the special conveyance of voyagers by sea.
Silence is this horse of wood,
Silence is the guide and support of men at sea.
This Silence which causes you annoyance
Is uttering cries of love audible to the spiritual.
You say, "How strange the spiritual man is silent!"
He answers, "How strange you have no ears!
Though I utter cries, you hear them not;
Sensual ears, however sharp, are deaf to my cries."
The spiritual man, as it were, cries in his sleep,
Uttering thousands of words of comfort;
While the carnal man at his side hears nothing at all,
For he is asleep, and deaf to the other's voice.
But the perfect spiritualist who has broken his boat
Plunges into the sea as a fish of the sea (of Truth).
He is then neither silent nor speaking, but a mystery.
No words are available to express his condition.
That marvelous one is in neither of these states
'Twould be irreverent to explain his state more fully.
These illustrations are weak and inappropriate,
But no fitter ones are obtainable from sensible objects.
When the eldest prince died, the youngest was sick and could not come; but
the second brother came to the court to attend his funeral. There the King
observed him, and took pity on him and entreated him kindly. He instilled
into him spiritual knowledge of the verities hidden beneath phenomenal
objects, and conveyed to him as deep a perception of spiritual truths as is
not gained by a Sufi after years of fasting and retirement from the world.
It is a fact, that when the pure spirit escapes from the bonds of the body,
God gives it sight to behold the things of the spirit. The logician denies
the possibility of this divine illumination of the heart, but he is confuted
by the Prophet, who swore "by the star" that the Koran was revealed to him
by divine illumination. 19 Those who cleave to their heresy (Bid'at) and
obstinate unbelief are like to incur the punishment inflected on the tribe
of 'Ad for disbelieving the Prophet Hud. 20 Earthly forms are only shadows
of the Sun of the Truth, a cradle for babes, but too small to hold those who
have grown to spiritual manhood. When the prince was thus nourished by the
spiritual food given him by the King, which was such as the angels of heaven
subsist upon, not the unspiritual food of Christians and those who give
partners to God, he began to be puffed up with self-conceit, and forgot what
he owed to the King, and rebelled against him. The King was cut to the heart
by his ingratitude, which exactly resembled that of Nimrod. When Nimrod was
an infant he was taken by his mother to sea, and the ship being wrecked, all
that were in it perished, save only the infant Nimrod who was saved through
the pity of Izrail, the Angel of Death. God spared him, and nurtured him
without the aid of mother or nurse; but when he grew up he proved
ungrateful, and was puffed up with self-conceit and egotism, and showed
enmity against God and Abraham His servant. When the prince found himself
cast off by the King he came to himself, and repented and humbled himself
with deep contrition. The King then pardoned him; but his doom had already
been decreed by God, and he was slain by the King he had injured,
acknowledging the King's goodness to him with his latest breath.
The death of the second prince.
In short, the vengeance of That Jealous One (God)
After one year bore him to the grave.
When the King awoke out of his trance to consciousness,
His Mars-like eyes shed tears of blood.
When that incomparable one looked into his quiver,
He saw that one of his arrow-shafts was missing.
He cried to God, "What has become of my arrow?"
God answered, "Thy arrow is fixed in his throat!"
That King, bountiful as the sea, had pardoned him;
Nevertheless his arrow had dealt him a mortal wound.
He was slain, and cried out with his last breath,
"The King is all in all, my slayer and my savior.
If he is not both these, he is not all in all;
Nay, he is both my slayer and my mourner!"
That expiring martyr also gave thanks,
That the King had smitten his body, not his spirit;
For the visible body must perforce perish,
Ere the spirit can live in happiness for evermore.
Though he incurred chastisement, it affected his body only,
And as a friend he now goes, free of pain, to his Friend.
Thus at first he clung to the King's stirrup,
But at last went his way guided by perfect sight.
Finally, the youngest brother, who was the weakest of all, succeeded where
his brothers had failed, and obtained his earthly mistress, the king's
daughter, as his bride, and the Spiritual Beloved as well.
Here the Masnavi breaks off; but, according to the Bulaq edition, the
following conclusion was supplied by Jalalu-'d-Din's son, Bahau-'d-Din
Sultan Valad:
Part of the story remains untold; it was retained
In his mind and was not disclosed.
The story of the princes remains unfinished,
The pearl of the third brother remains unstrung.
Here speech, like a camel, breaks down on its road;
I will say no more, but guard my tongue from speech.
The rest is told without aid of tongue
To the heart of him whose spirit is alive.
1. Koran lxvii. 10.
2. Surat, or "form," means picture, image, outward appearance as opposed to
reality, conception or "form of thought," the "architypes" or "ideas" in the
Divine mind, "the Substantial forms" of the Realist philosophy. Here the
poet runs through nearly all these meanings.
3. Sale's Koran, p. 75, note.
4. i.e., the architypes in the "Intellectual Presence" or "world of
command," which are afterwards set forth in the "world of creation or
sensible objects.
5. See Koran xlii. 9.
6. i.e., the similitudes used in the Koran.
7. "The Truth," Al Haqq, the Divine Noumenon.
8. See Gulshan i Raz, Answer III., and the Hadis, "Whoso knows himself knows
his Lord."
9. Koran xxvii. 16.
10. Simurgh, "Oiseau extraordinaire qui reside au Caucase," as M. Garcin de
Tassy calls it, means "thirty birds" (Si murgh), and is used as a type of
the Divine Unity which embraces all plurality.
11. i.e., the prophets and saints.
12. Koran x. 37.
13. Koran lxv. 2.
14. i.e., "The Rule of Position."Khulasat ul Hisab, Book iv.
15. Freytag, Arabum Proverbia, ii. 379.
16. Koran ii. 213.
17. Koran lxv. 7.
18. i.e., hardened sinners like Pharaoh.
19. Koran liii. 1.
20. Koran xlvi. 20.

Note on Apocryphal Supplements to the Masnavi.
In the Lucknow edition there follows an epilogue written by Muhammad Ilahi
Bakhsh, giving a continuation of the story of the third brother, but nothing
of the kind is found in any of the other editions.
The Bulaq edition adds a so-called Book VII., but this is known to be a
comparatively recent forgery. Haji Khalfa says: "It is notorious that the
Masnavi is contained in six books, but a seventh book has made its
appearance, put forth by Ismail Dadah, the commentator. He also wrote a
commentary on it, and therein replied with eloquence and strenuousness to
those who denied its genuineness. He says in his commentary that when he
came to write out his fifth volume in the year 1035 A.H., he met with Book
VII. in a copy of the Masnavi dated 814 A.H. He bought it and read it
through, and was satisfied that it was undoubtedly a composition of the
author of the Masnavi. But the other Darveshes of the Maulavi order denied
the genuineness of the Seventh Book." 1
The contents of this Seventh Book consist of comments on various texts and
traditions, illustrated by stories of no interest. They have nothing in
common with the Epilogue of Muhammad Ilahi Bakhsh, found in the Lucknow
1. Haji Khalfa, v. 377. Ismai1 was a Darvesh of the Maulavi order, surnamed
Anguravi, from his native place Anguri, in Anatolia.