Down With Plain English

HomeFunplexLanguage and English

Down With Plain English

From the Michigan Law Journal, 5/97, written by one Alan Falk, a
Commissioner of the MI Court of Appeals, in Lansing... as a letter to
the editor of same.

"On behalf of abecedarians and logodaedalophiles, I rise to denounce the
paraphasts who wish to foist a "Plain English" law upon us.

Never mind that these soi-disant aolists have battologically assailed us
in the pages of our professional journal, condemning the lexiphanes and
logodaedalist with the same broad brush, in a feeding frenzy of
ergotismic bootstrapping.

Must we all be consigned to become monoglots? There is an anecdote in
the banking industry. It seems a large East-coast bank was expanding
and planning to buy a small western financial institution. The
accountants from the home office were going over the books, trying to
put a price tag on the transaction. They found that a great deal of
collateral loans were "eewees" (they were cacoepists, suffering from
otosis). After much confusion, they were overhead by the janitor, who
knew the word for an adult female sheep ("ewe") when he heard it. What
is "common and everyday" language to the logomachists advocating a Plain
English Law may be inadequate to the task for we lesser mortals, who
have come to appreciate that the right terminology, supported by
commonly available lexicographic sources, is preferable to the
periphrasis of writing everything in crayon.

Let's do away with these somniloquent spintexts and quodlibertarians,
the way comedian Stan Freeburg did with "Mr. Tweeter", who wanted to
bowdlerize the song "Old Man River" ("Elderly Man River, that Elderly
Man River, he doesn't know anything, he doesn't say anything...")

The Plain English Movement achieves an acme of risibility when its own
purveyors acknowledge ("Why We Need a Plain English Law") that even they
cannot wholly explain what their own Michigan bill, if enacted, would

Shunting aside the ironic hypocrisy, the jurisprudentially sensitive
will be alert to the fact that such a law violates elementary notions of
due process, and would consequently be void for vagueness, since people
of common understanding would necessarily have to guess at its meaning.

Let, therefore, these engastrimyths speak for the xylophalic, not for
those of us who use, understand, and appreciate the mellifluous, the
alliterative, and the lexi-cographically precise."

More Language and English

  1. [page] A Prayer For Sid Klein
  2. [page] A Pronunciation Exercise
  3. [page] American English Vs The Real McCoy
  4. [page] Apostrophe
  5. [page] Ask Mr Language Person
  6. [page] B O O K Tm
  7. [page] Book Potatos
  8. [page] Bookstores
  9. [page] Buzz Word Synthesizer
  10. [page] Correct Definitions
  11. [page] Dave Barry On Grammar
  12. [page] Double Positive
  13. [page] Doublespeak
  14. [page] Down With Plain English
  15. [page] End Of The World Headlines
  16. [page] Gender Grammar
  17. [page] Grammar Police
  18. [page] Grammar And Spelling Troubles
  19. [page] Green Eggs And Hamlet
  20. [page] Had Had Had Had Had Had Had A Riddle
  21. [page] Hamlet Was Really A College Student: The Literary Evidence
  22. [page] Hemingway Sightings
  23. [page] How To Address A Politically-Correct, Non-Sexist Business Letter
  24. [page] How To Phrase It
  25. [page] How To Talk To People
  26. [page] Important Vocabulary
  27. [page] It Is Fundamentally True That The Terms Below Are In English
  28. [page] Jabberwocky After A Trial By Spell Checker
  29. [page] Journalists And The Stock Market
  30. [page] Language Barriers
  31. [page] Language Trends Of The Future
  32. [page] Medieval Vs Modern English
  33. [page] New Definitions
  34. [page] Only
  35. [page] Only Dweebs Read Books!!
  36. [page] Oops!! Coca Cola Typo!!
  37. [page] Opposites
  38. [page] Oxymorons
  39. [page] PC Little Red Riding Hood
  40. [page] Plurals
  41. [page] Poem About A Spell Checker
  42. [page] Porpoises
  43. [page] Pun-ny
  44. [page] Regional Humor Page
  45. [page] Roses Are Red
  46. [page] Shakespearian Insult Kit
  47. [page] Shakespearian Insults
  48. [page] Simian Shakespeare
  49. [page] Sniglets
  50. [page] Stop That Bulletin!!
  51. [page] Tandem Story
  52. [page] Taters
  53. [page] The Duel
  54. [page] The History Of The English Language
  55. [page] The Importance Of Correct Punctuation
  56. [page] The Pluperfect Virus
  57. [page] The Ten Commandments In Ebonics
  58. [page] The Three Little Politically Correct Pigs
  59. [page] The Top 16 Plays Shakespeare Chose Not To Publish
  60. [page] This Is The Title Of This Story, Which Is Also Found Several Times In The Story Itself
  61. [page] Verbose Mother Goose
  62. [page] Verbose Writing
  63. [page] Verbs Is Fun
  64. [page] Vowels To Bosnia
  65. [page] Worst Paragraph Winners